Government shutdown: Jobs report is missing in action. Here's another take.
Government shutdown is expected to delay Friday's jobs report, but there are alternative measures: The ADP job report, released Wednesday, puts job creation for September at 166,000.
It’s a gauge of the job market – to most Americans the most basic indicator of prosperity and well-being. Beyond that, it’s a broad barometer of the economy’s health.
And this month, it’ll be missing in action.
At least that’s the way it appears so far, due to a partial shutdown of the federal government, which took effect Tuesday because the parties in Congress are at loggerheads over federal spending and President Obama’s health-care reform law.
With the shutdown on, don’t expect a Labor Department jobs report as usual this Friday. Instead, the best read of the job market so far comes from the private-sector firm ADP, which releases its own estimate of private-sector job creation each month, a couple of days ahead of the Labor Department's.
That ADP job-creation total for September, released Wednesday, is 166,000.
This net number of jobs created in the private sector is a bit below what economists were expecting in both the ADP and the Labor reports. But it’s also a bit stronger than the prior month.
The economic import: Job creation was at least chugging along, although still at a tepid pace, prior to the federal shutdown.
Paul Ashworth, chief US economist at Capital Economics in Toronto, calls the ADP number “relatively disappointing.” Economists were expecting a figure of about 180,000, and monthly numbers topping 200,000 would be more encouraging at a time of still-high unemployment.
Mark Zandi, chief economist of Moody’s Analytics, which collaborates with ADP in releasing the report, said, “The job market appears to have softened in recent months. Fiscal austerity has begun to take a toll on job creation. The runup in interest rates may also be doing some damage to jobs in the financial services industry.”
Still, both he and Mr. Ashworth see some resilience in the job market.
Ashworth, in a written analysis Wednesday morning, cites a relatively upbeat trend in claims for unemployment benefits, running at about 300,000 per week. “And yesterday we learned that the ISM manufacturing employment index strengthened further in September.”
A huge question, of course, is what happens next.
If the government shutdown lasts longer than a week or two, it could do some noticeable damage to the private-sector economy – temporarily dampening consumer spending as throngs of federal employees remain on unpaid furlough.
Beyond that, Congress soon will need to act to raise the nation’s debt limit, the amount the Treasury is allowed to borrow to help pay national bills. If the partisan standoff in Congress delays action on the debt ceiling, the economic consequences could quickly become more serious.
Back in 2011, the last time Congress stepped near the brink of a default on federal obligations, the stock market dropped significantly, and Standard & Poor’s downgraded its rating of US sovereign debt.
Many prognosticators are hopeful that the fiscal debates in Washington will be resolved, at least temporarily, in a way that allows the economic recovery to continue.
ADP is a large provider of payroll-processing services for employers, and derives its job estimate from trends in its own business. The monthly reports tend to track fairly closely with the Labor Department’s own estimates, which are based on employer survey responses.
Another estimate, by the firm TrimTabs and based on daily withholding-tax flows, estimates that the economy added 159,000 jobs in September.