Bush tax cuts 101: Would extension boost the economic recovery?
The short answer is yes. Forecasters anticipate that extending the Bush tax cuts, as well as other measures in the Obama-GOP deal, will breathe life into the economic recovery.
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
However controversial the tax breaks are for their politics, that's the view of many professional forecasters.
For one, the proposed extension of Bush-era tax rates would prevent Americans from having to pay more taxes next year amid an already weak economic recovery, they say. Moreover, other parts of the deal struck between Mr. Obama and Republican leaders – notably a payroll tax cut and measures to help businesses – could add fuel to the recovery.
That's not to say the tax cuts are a panacea for all the economy's troubles. And with Mr. Obama under fire from his own party for agreeing to extend tax cuts for the richest Americans, the plan's passage by Congress in the days ahead isn't a sure thing.
But forecasters say the tax deal could account for as much as 1 percent of economic growth in 2011 – a number that could be enough to rev up a now-tepid recovery and begin to reduce the nation's high unemployment rate.
Richard Berner, chief US economist at the investment firm Morgan Stanley, says the package of tax breaks would boost his forecast for economic growth next year to about 4 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), up from his current view of 3 percent. Beyond the direct effects of a cash infusion into the pockets of consumers and businesses, the tax cuts could have some benefits that are hard to forecast, he says in a report for clients.
"It would reduce the uncertainty around the tax issue, [and such] clarity could be a plus for growth," Mr. Berner and colleague David Greenlaw write. "Second, it could boost investors’ risk appetite, which would further ease financial conditions."
At least some cuts were anticipated
Prior to this week's bargain, economists had already based their forecasts on an extension of at least some of the Bush tax cuts. But the deal included some surprises with positive implications for growth, like a temporary payroll tax cut worth $120 billion.
Failure to reach a deal would cause economists to cut their forecasts for growth. For example, a White House memo Wednesday cited forecasts that a failure to extend the Bush tax cuts for the middle class could shave 1.7 percent off of gross domestic product in 2011.