Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

The Last Stand

Gen. George Custer for US president? Not if Ulysses S. Grant could help it.

By / May 5, 2010

The Last Stand: Custer, Sitting Bull, and the Battle of the Little Big Horn By Nathaniel Philbrick Viking Adult 496 pp., $30


Like a long-haired rock star prancing about the stage in super-tight jeans, Gen. George Custer eschewed comfort for style in Davey Crocket-style buckskin pants and shirts that shrank in the sun, even though light and fast-drying cotton was by then a commonly worn cloth.

Skip to next paragraph

“His uniform was spotless and fitted him like the skin on a sausage,” one officer recalls in Nathaniel Philbrick’s eighth and newest book, The Last Stand: Custer, Sitting Bull, and the Battle of the Little Big Horn. It’s a typical example of the great detail offered in this story of a passionate, ambitious man whose flamboyant, irrational style earned him fame, enemies, and death at age 36.

Philbrick is a meticulous historian. His previous book, “Mayflower,” was a finalist for the 2007 Pulitzer Prize in History. An otherwise upbeat Monitor review of “Mayflower” qualified that, “Philbrick spends too little time on the big picture and too much on arcane detail, making for many dry passages.” Unfortunately, that problem continues in this book. While offering interesting tidbits, tedious minutiae and irrelevant details bog down what could be a riveting narrative.

Meanwhile, interesting asides receive little attention or elaboration. Philbrick mentions, for example, that Sitting Bull, after defeating Custer at the Battle of Little Bighorn, went on tour with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show, but never explains why the great chief subjected himself to such silliness. Moreover, Philbrick buries his important hypothesis – that Custer is a scapegoat for the 1876 military fiasco that granted him immortality in US history books.

At age 23, Custer had become one of America’s youngest-ever generals, helping Abraham Lincoln’s troops win the battles of Bull Run, Gettysburg, and Appomattox. These successes made him a popular political figure (he stumped for President Andrew Johnson) with sights set on the White House. But he was a bitter rival to Ulysses S. Grant. Custer was the only West Point cadet to match Grant’s record in riding and jumping, a fact that Custer seemed eager to flaunt when he bolted in front of Grant during the Union’s victory procession into Washington, D.C.

Animosity bubbled up again when Custer implicated both Grant’s secretary of war and brother in a corruption scheme concerning Army forts, though Custer’s claims were speculative. Incensed, Grant tried to sideline Custer by pulling him from fighting in the West. This would have saved Custer’s life had not Custer himself insisted on returning to Montana to storm the village of 8,000 Lakota and Northern Cheyenne Indians headed by Sitting Bull, who had grown tired of America’s growing demand for land and shunned the government’s call for him to live and hunt on a reservation.


Read Comments

View reader comments | Comment on this story