UN aid debate: Give cash, not food?

The United Nations World Food Program meets Tuesday in Rome to discuss the global food crisis.

from the June 3, 2008 edition

Page 2 of 2

Page 1 | 2

It is the latest example of mobile phones helping people in remote areas of the developing world. Farmers receive market information sent directly to their phones and health workers use them to collect epidemiological data or to distribute advice.

"If we think of bringing in food items in an emergency then we want to respond as quickly as possible," says Anne Ejakait, who runs the cash program for Concern. This technology can get the money here in minutes compared with the very difficult logistics of bringing in food."

The technology has passed by Tarik Tealei Teresha until now. She does not know her own age – probably somewhere in her 60s – much less how to work the mobile phone she has been given to share with nine other families.

"This system is good," she says, "but that's as much as I know."

It is a month since she has eaten meat.

Like most people here, she is only able to afford one meal of thick maize porridge a day. Where once she would have cooked a chicken or beef stew to go with it, now she is surviving on the fleshy fruit of the Taralakwo tree.

"When I get the money I will buy maize, meat, and milk for the children," she says, waiting patiently for her phone to beep with 320 shillings ($5) per person in her family – enough for about a fortnight's food.

Food is too expensive to buy

Her story is typical in an area where the government-supporting Pokot tribe clashed with the Tugen, who backed Kenya's opposition party during December's election.

Wilson Lokopwa, the local chief, says: "After the election they started killing people, burning homes. Stores of maize were taken from homes and cattle and goats were stolen.

"Now there is maize in the market but it is more expensive and people are hungry."

As chief, he worked with other community leaders and Concern to draw up criteria on who would be eligible for cash and who would not be.

The result was about 550 households in need of urgent help.

They targeted women in order to make sure the cash would be spent on household goods.

Aid workers will now monitor their spending to see if it is worth extending the program.

Tricia O'Rourke, of the aid agency Oxfam, says it is high time the WFP caught up with that latest thinking in food aid policy.

"It's something that we have been calling for some time – that we should be moving towards this type of aid," she says. "It's just a shame that it had to come to a crisis like this for the WFP to catch up."

1 | Page 2