Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search


Iraqi media braves assault from all sides

Reporters there say they face a growing threat from feuding political factions.

By Sam DagherCorrespondent of The Christian Science Monitor / December 20, 2007



Baghdad

For the fifth year in a row, Iraq was the most dangerous place in the world to be a journalist. The New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists reported this week that 31 journalists have died in 2007, one fewer than a year ago.

Skip to next paragraph

The media watchdog group said that 173 have died since 2003, including 49 media support workers – the drivers, translators, and guards who work for media companies and help report the news.

The vast majority of those killed are Iraqis – who have not only been targeted by insurgent groups but who also appear to be facing a growing campaign of harassment, kidnapping, and assault at the hands of government officials and Iraqi politicians.

Those working for print, television, radio, and other outlets say they are sometimes bribed to relay the views and pronouncements of the organization that funds their operations or paid off by politicians who want positive coverage. Others say they face ongoing pressure from the US military, as illustrated by the case of award-winning Associated Press photographer Bilal Hussein, who was accused by the US of being linked to terrorists, a charge that his employer denies.

"We thought the fall of [Saddam Hussein] would usher in a new era of press freedom, but now all of that has been quashed by religious institutions and the government itself. We all practice self-censorship for one reason or another," says one Iraqi journalist, who asked not to be named.

The numerous cases of intimidation that Iraqi journalists describe reveal a country still coming to terms with a free press, but also highlight the extreme risks many here are willing to take in hopes that their country will eventually embrace this fundamental aspect of democracy.

Cameraman Adnan Haseeb says he still doesn't know why he was arrested and imprisoned for almost nine months. He blames secret agents working for Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki for his kidnapping and eventual torture.

Mr. Haseeb says he was on assignment in the Green Zone on March 8 with Al-Hurriya television when he was escorted by two armed men in civilian clothes to Mr. Maliki's office. He described being locked in a room for a few hours without explanation. That night, he says, he and a colleague were transported to a prison at the Muthana air base close by. The colleague, arrested at the same time, was later released and told to collect 1 million dinars ($833) from Maliki's office, according to the station.

While blindfolded and handcuffed, Haseeb says he was beaten and threatened during numerous interrogations. At first, he says, he was accused of working with insurgents, then of being involved in a March bombing in Baghdad.

Haseeb was released in late November without explanation. Now, he says, he fears for his life.

Maliki's media adviser, Yassin Majid, says he knows nothing about the incident and denies anyone in the prime minister's office was involved. But Al-Hurriya's director, Fayrouz Hatem, says she brought up Haseeb's case to Maliki personally in the presence of Mr. Majid in May.

Ms. Hatem says she believes the whole episode may have been instigated by someone within the government or close to the government who was displeased with the channel's programming. Before his detention, Haseeb was the cameraman for Al-Makshouf, or Exposed, which covers citizen grievances with the government.

"The biggest threat for Iraqi journalists these days are the feuding political parties," says Hatem, who moved back to Iraq from Sweden more than a year ago. Like dozens of other employees, she lives at the station. The channel has had three of its reporters killed since its inception in 2004.

"I went home two months ago and my neighbors told me it would be best not to come back because there are militiamen that think my line of work is immoral," says Al-Hurriya news presenter Marwa Ahmed.

Faeq al-Oqabi also lives at Al-Hurriya. For the past month Mr. Oqabi, who survived three assassination attempts and almost had his son kidnapped, has been sleeping in a room that doubles as his office in preparation for the relaunch of his controversial show, "Let's Talk," a call-in program that is highly critical of the government.

He left his old employer, the state-funded Iraqiya television, because he says it wanted to censor his show due to pressure from the government. "You face death from every direction the moment you raise your voice," he says.

The precautions these journalists exercise are understandable. Last Friday Ali al-Moussawi, who worked for Alive in Baghdad, a US-supported and Internet-based video reports project about the lives of Iraqis, was shot 31 times at his home in the capital's Sadr City district.

On Tuesday, a group of Iraqi journalists, some working for foreign news organizations, were accompanying police officials in Karbala to report on security measures in the city south of Baghdad when they were brutally beaten up by guards in the passing convoy of an Iraqi political leader.

But there appear to be slivers of hope, too. In the semiautonomous Kurdish north, where journalists have been harassed or imprisoned for what they write or say, regional President Massoud Barzani promised to reject a bill being considered by the region's parliament to regulate reporters' topics. In October, a group of reporters started working on their own code of conduct, with help from the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).

Karim Hamadi, a prominent Baghdad journalist, says he's hopeful the press will find its bearings one day.

"We are on the path to having a professional media. Yes, there are a lot of pressures, but our experience is nascent and it's unfair to compare us to others," he says.

Permissions