Do longer hours equal more learning?
Pressured to produce better students, 10 Massachusetts public schools pack more hours into their schedules.
(Page 2 of 2)
Because there's time for project-based learning and collaboration, teachers in pilot schools throughout the state were "shocked" at how satisfying it was to teach a longer day, says Anne Wass, president of the Massachusetts Teachers Association. All teachers are paid for the additional time.Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
Of the more than 100 teachers and staff at Salemwood, just three opted to transfer to other schools before the start of the new schedule in 2006-07, Eckel says.
Parents are solidly behind the change as well. Fifty families transferred their children last year, but 70 others enrolled. Of the parents surveyed by Massachusetts 2020 at three of the pilot schools, 77 percent said their child was doing better in school as a result of the expanded schedule.
Mary Shank is one of those true believers. "It gives us extra time to get home from working," she says, waiting outside to pick up her kids as a choral class rehearses on the steps. "My son is developmentally delayed, and he's doing awesome now. He's willing to do homework when you ask him, and he's not having as many troubles."
That's not to say the extended day has been easy for everyone, or universally accepted.
Salemwood assistant Principal Phyllis Brandano noticed a slight uptick in behavioral problems. "It's a long day for a 6-year-old, let's just face it." Next year, the school will end at 3:15 instead of 3:30, to give teachers time to offer makeup tests or hold students after school for disciplinary infractions.
Some towns that considered extending school days couldn't reach consensus with parents or unions. Concerns ranged from loss of after-school sports or family time to logistical issues such as having children going home on dark winter afternoons. A mother who visited Salemwood with a team of visitors from Southbridge, Mass., to explore the idea of expanding their school day expressed skepticism. She leaned toward feeling that it's a family's responsibility to take advantage of opportunities for after-school enrichment, and she wondered why her daughter should have to stay extra hours because other students are behind academically.
But the potential benefits have sparked the interest of more than 80 schools in Massachusetts, and they're putting together plans for lengthening their days in 2008-09.
Shifting away from the schedule that has pervaded US schools since the 1960s isn't new. In the 1980s, the landmark report "A Nation at Risk" raised the idea of extending the school day. Another push came in 1994 with the report "Prisoners of Time."
'Buy in' is critical to schedule success
Massachusetts is leading the way this time and is poised to double the grant budget to $13 million for next year. But a number of states, districts, and schools – from Connecticut to New Mexico – have also considered or implemented longer schedules.
There's no guarantee that the momentum will yield widespread change, but the prospects are stronger than they've ever been, says Elena Silva, a senior policy analyst at Education Sector in Washington, who recently examined how schools use time. Expanding learning time is advocated by the $60 million Strong American Schools campaign launched by the Gates and Broad foundations and a variety of such proposals are in the works on Capitol Hill, as well.
"At its core, it's a good idea," Ms. Silva says by phone. "My biggest concern with it is that people will not plan it well.... Without the buy-in from teachers and their community, it's not going to be very successful." She hopes that well-designed programs will be supported long enough (five to 10 years) to yield solid data on what's effective.
After a year of working out the kinks, Eckel has offered some advice to interested districts. The scheduling shifts require complex planning, he says, and his school will be making tweaks for next year. For one thing, he'll spread the enrichment classes throughout the week, he says, "so we won't have one 'Wacky Wednesday' where the world turns upside down."