Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

  • Advertisements

Broad backlash to Putin reforms

The Russian president is losing popular support over his pension reforms and 'managed democracy.'

By Staff writer for The Christian Science Monitor / January 19, 2005



MOSCOW

More than a week of growing protests across Russia - sparked by reforms to the welfare system - are a rare challenge to Vladimir Putin and signal trouble for the once widely popular president.

Skip to next paragraph

Although Mr. Putin on Monday blamed his government for inept handling of the law, which came into force Jan. 1, scores of protesters for the first time are aiming their anger directly at the president. Millions of pensioners began receiving meager cash handouts in place of Soviet-era benefits such as free public transportation, free medicine, and utility subsidies.

"Nobody ever believed there could be so much social dissent about pensions, but [Putin's] reputation could be seriously damaged or broken by 2006," says Lilia Shevtsova, a political analyst at the Carnegie Moscow Center. "Only two things have kept him going: [high] oil prices and lack of alternatives. If people are unhappy, they start looking for alternatives," she says.

Results released last week of a poll by ROMIR Monitoring, of 1,500 Russians in more than 100 cities, found that 49 percent agreed that current policies were leading to a "dead end." Only 38 percent felt otherwise. That result is a turnaround from a year ago, when a similar poll found that just 29 percent agreed Russia was heading toward a "dead end," while 53 percent agreed the country was on the right path.

"In all, the implication was the sense of ambiguity and injustice, discrepancy between the official statements that the economy is growing and the lack of practical progress in living standards," ROMIR director Nikolai Popov told Novaya Izvestia newspaper.

But erasing subsidies is just one of a host of changes that point to a risky Kremlin agenda that will determine the shape of politics in Russia for years to come. They include the end of direct elections for regional governors and the start of a party-list system for electing deputies that favors the ruling United Russia party.

Critics see the changes as a deliberate reversal of once-budding democracy; the Kremlin calls the new authoritarian trend "managed democracy."

"In Russia we can talk about the end of politics," says Ms. Shevtsova.

"The trend is quite serious, because the president has dismantled all democratic checks and balances. He is creating a political desert," she says.

Putin was elected to a second term last March, and despite the slow-burn conflict in Chechnya and a string of terrorist attacks, he has long had popularity ratings of 80 percent or higher that are the envy of most Western politicians. Putin has symbolized a welcome degree of stability for many Russians after the unbridled Boris Yeltsin years of the 1990s, immediately following the collapse of the Soviet Union.

But events of late are taking some of the shine off Putin's rule.

Authorities drafted a controversial antiterror bill after the Beslan school hostage drama. The bill is a smorgasbord of get-tough measures, such as being able to declare a state of emergency that vastly increases the powers of the security services at the expense of civil liberties.

Vague wording means that even protesting pensioners fear the bill could be used to crack down on them, or any dissent not related to terror. Legislation enacted last year already restricts public protests.

Permissions