Two approaches to school accountability

A leading issue in the last presidential campaign, education has been nearly off the radar in a race fixed on the question: Will the nation be safe? Still, there are clues in the 2004 campaign on another national security issue: Will the nation be smart?

US taxpayers spend more than $500 billion a year on K-12 education, but American student achievement lags behind that in many other industrialized nations. Not even 1 in 3 American fourth and eighth graders meets US proficiency standards in reading and mathematics. Black and Hispanic students still often score several grade levels below their white counterparts.

Faced with these challenges, both President Bush and John Kerry supported the No Child Left Behind Act, which uses federal dollars to leverage changes in everything from how often students are tested to the consequences for school systems if children are not learning.

But if both agree in principle that Washington has a role in improving local schools, they still have significant disagreements on education, seen in their sparring over No Child Left Behind. For President Bush, the backlash against NCLB signals that reform is working. In a second term, he would stay the course: Make needed adjustments, then expand its principles into the nation's high schools.

For Senator Kerry, the outcry signals a need to fund the law more fully - and possibly to revise it. Leading Kerry supporters, including the nation's teachers unions, oppose the law.

"One thing that is encouraging is that both candidates see closing the achievement gap as the most important problem in public education. The differences are in tone and approach, rather than a big deep philosophical divide," says Ross Wiener, policy director of the Education Trust, a research and advocacy group for poor students.

Both Bush and Kerry support preschool and after-school programs, but differ over the future of Head Start, a popular preschool program. Bush wants Head Start to shift emphasis to developing literacy skills and turn over control of the program to the states. Kerry says Head Start should be fully funded so that every eligible child can attend. He also proposes a "School's Open 'Til Six" initiative for some 3.5 million children.

The next occupant of the White House could also have a significant impact on higher education. With college tuition costs rising and state spending on colleges decreasing, Washington faces increased pressure to step in with more funding, especially as Congress reauthorizes the Higher Education Act next year. President Bush proposes year-round Pell Grants for low-income students. Kerry is offering a tax credit of up to $4,000 of tuition for every year in college, as well as federal aid to states that curb tuition hikes.

But on the campaign trail, and over the next four years, the No Child Left Behind law will remain front and center in education policy.

Page: 1 | 2