Saudi Arabia's quiet voices of reform start to speak up

Over dates and coffee spiced with ginger and cardamom, a group of 12 men has gathered to plot a peaceful revolution. The goal: to introduce democratic ideals in Saudi Arabia.

This fledgling reform movement - which has come into the open since Sept. 11 - promotes basic concepts by Western standards. The men debate the need to establish human rights groups, elected officials, and a new constitution that creates an independent judiciary.

But in Saudi Arabia these voices are innovative and rebellious.

Several members of the group, including its unofficial leader, professor of literature Abdullah al-Hamad, were jailed, fired, or demoted in the 1990s after calling for reform of the Saudi political system: an alliance between the ruling Saud royal family and a deeply conservative religious establishment. The Constitution is based on the Koran and political participation and free speech are denied.

Yet since Sept. 11, a tentative shift has begun, says Mohammed al-Mohaissen, a teacher of Arabic, who serves as secretary for the reform group.

"[Sept. 11] raised a lot of questions," he says. "What was behind it? Who was responsible? The government realized it must listen to inside voices and give a margin of freedom for these questions to be discussed. A red line has been crossed allowing our concerns to be expressed."

But the group dismisses a new Saudi initiative, released Monday by Crown Prince Abdullah bin Abdul Aziz, that promotes the political reform of Arab regimes.

"I believe he is sincere, but for his thoughts to be credible, they must first be applied in Saudi Arabia," says Mr. Mohaissen. "I also believe that he has reflected many of our ideas and so perhaps news of our discussions has already reached him."

Members of the group, who meet once a week, are still careful and uncertain that the freedom to speak out will last. But they are no longer covert. They have been interviewed in recent months on regional satellite television channels, including Al Jazeera, and have inspired similar gatherings across Saudi Arabia.

A letter outlining their ideas is being prepared and Mohaissen hopes to present it in person to Crown Prince Abdullah in the coming weeks. He expects to have 100 signatures of support from academics and intellectuals across the country.

"Reform is coming and I feel it like a current," says Mohaissen. "No one can stop it this time."

Analysts say that while Sept. 11 did not cause the move toward reform - many of these ideas were being debated long beforehand - the shock of the attacks on America has added urgency to the debate.

That urgency has been felt across the Middle East. Egypt recently named its first woman judge. Gulf states have begun to expand political and press freedoms. Bahrain recently held democratic parliamentary elections for the first time in 30 years in which women were also allowed to vote and run as candidates.

"I think Bahrain has taken a very large step in terms of political reform," says Khalid al Dakheel, a social science professor at King Saud University in Riyadh, who is outspoken on the need for reform. "We need to do that here in Saudi Arabia. The irony is that Saudi Arabia pioneered the consultative process in the 1920s but has become the last Gulf country to jump onto the wagon of political participation. I think it is inevitable now."

Since Sept. 11, the Saudi government has taken tentative steps toward social reform. Crown Prince Abdullah recently visited poor Saudi families in a Riyadh suburb, acknowledging for the first time that the country's recipe for a desert Utopia - oil wealth and religion - was not delivering.

Page: 1 | 2