Whales to Navy: Less noise, please

Not so, says Marsh Green, president of the Ocean Mammal Institute in Reading, Pa. "There is a significant body of research showing that whales avoid underwater sounds starting at 110-120 decibels," says Dr. Green, an animal behavior specialist. (One hundred forty decibels is considered harmful to humans. The decibel scale is logarithmic, which means that a noise seems twice as loud for every increase of 10 decibels.)

"The sonar sound field around the transmitting ship will be 180 decibels up to 1 km away and 150-160 decibels up to 160 km away," adds Green. "This means that many marine animals will be exposed to LFA sonar levels capable of causing stranding and, possibly, lung hemorrhaging over large areas of the ocean."

Sixteen whales beached themselves in the Bahamas last summer, shortly after the Navy conducted active sonar exercises in the vicinity. Volunteers pushed most of the whales back into the ocean, but seven died - apparently victims of sound pressure that caused cranial hemorrhaging.

"That incident unequivocally demonstrated the lethality of high-powered sonars," says Kenneth Balcomb, a marine biologist who witnessed the episode.

Even the rescued whales have not been seen since, leading researchers to believe that they, too, perished. "The whales that we observed swimming toward shore and stranding were only temporary survivors of an acoustic holocaust that can be likened to fishing with dynamite," says Dr. Balcomb, executive director of the Center for Whale Research in Friday Harbor, Wash.

Whales also beached themselves following earlier naval sonar exercises in Greece, California, and the Canary Islands.

The debate comes at a time when the Navy's submarine force is fighting for its future as Pentagon analysts advising the Bush administration question the need for expensive underwater assets developed since World War II. Part of that fight for submariners is acquiring the ability to do their job more effectively and at longer range - which they insist the LFA sonar can provide.

Not only are diesel-electric (nonnuclear) submarines increasing around the world (21 countries now have them), they are becoming quieter and thus harder to detect using conventional means. Vice Admiral Malcolm Fages, who until his recent promotion headed the Pentagon's program on submarine warfare, says "The program is very, very important to us."

But whether they consider themselves environmental activists or simply enjoy whale watching, many Americans have a strong desire to see marine mammals protected. This is reflected in growing congressional concern.

"A substantial body of convincing science exists pointing to the potential dangers of this system for whales and other marine animals," says U. S. Rep. John Baldacci (D) of Maine.

"The evidence is disturbing, and given the range of science on this issue, the only prudent course of action would be for NMFS to deny these permits until additional studies and tests can be conducted and assessed."

Page: 1 | 2