Bringing the Birds Back to Assisi
Hunters nearly killed off the songbirds of St. Francis; Bert Schwarzschild helps protect them. CONSERVATION
EVERY September in Florence, Italy, the Fiesta Degli Uccelli (Fair of the Birds) ushers in the new hunting season. The Viale Machiavelli is blocked off, and hunters display guns, ammunition, and wild songbirds in cages (used to attract free-flying birds). But this year the only unusual sight on the street were some black-boardered notices lamenting the ``death'' of the fair.Skip to next paragraph
Subscribe Today to the Monitor
Hunting in general, and the hunting of songbirds in particular, is under fire in Italy (which is located on a major songbird migration path).
Throughout the country, conservationists rally for revised hunting laws. Petitions circulate, politicians speak out. A Rome-based newspaper poll in December 1986 found that 80 percent of the public wanted some reduction or the total abolition of hunting in Italy.
Watching from the sidelines is American Bert Schwarzschild, who began a songbird campaign in Italy in 1983. Mr. Schwarzschild played a significant role in prompting the Italian public to rethink a tradition he calls ``barbaric'' and ``unsporting.''
Songbirds are a delicacy in Italy, and are roasted, baked in bread, and prepared in other ways. Schwarzschild's concerns led to a national campaign in Italy, and the establishment of the Assisi Bird Council/Europe, which he co-founded with Maria Luisa Cohen in 1984.
Rousing thought is practically second nature for Schwarzschild, an electrical engineer-turned-environmentalist. ``I've always had an empathy for the plights of other people and the plight of other living beings,'' says the soft-spoken, Berkeley, Calif. activist. He was national director of the Whale Center in Oakland, Ca., executive director of the American Youth Hostels, and chairman of the US education committee for the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources. He also founded an American branch of the Assisi Bird Council.
Schwarzschild found the impetus for his Assisi Bird Campaign while vacationing in Italy in 1983. He was intrigued with the idea of hiking up Mt. Subasio, the place where Saint Francis of Assisi befriended birds and animals in the 13th century.
``As I started walking up, I heard shotgun blasts in the valley below,'' Schwartzchild recalls. ``Then I started to notice hundreds of shotgun casings on the trail, and feathers in the bushes. And I realized I didn't hear a single songbird. ... The songbirds of Saint Francis were no more, and had been decimated by hunters.''
According to the International Council for Bird Preservation in Oxford, England, hundreds of millions of songbirds (perhaps 15 percent of those migrating) are shot, trapped, netted, or caught with lime-sticks (branches that are coated with a sticky substance) as they travel the Mediterranean flyway. Some of the hunting is legal, some is not. Italy has the second-largest concentration of hunters in the world, after Malta.
``There's a war going on between hunters and protectionists,'' says Dr. Yves Lecocq, secretary general of the Federation of Hunters' Associations fo the EEC (FACE) in Brussels, Belgium. ``It's not by banning that the situation will improve,'' he says. He would rather talk to the hunting groups, and get them to ``intensify their education for members.''
FACE, which lobbies the European Economic Community on behalf of hunters, condemned Italy in 1987 for hunting 11 species of birds and mammals protected in other European countries. Italian hunting laws are permissive and poorly enforced, says Dr. Lecocq.
Lecocq is quick to defend Italian hunters, however, and says songbird hunting is ``often an emotional issue.'' ``We think that [hunting] should only be discussed on a scientific basis, and as long as it can be viewed as wise use, nothing is wrong with it.''
``According to research, more birds are killed in the UK and Germany by domestic cats than birds in Italy,'' he says. ``But it doesn't excuse what is sometimes happening in Italy'' with illegal hunting, he says.
Besides launching a campaign to save songbirds, in 1983 Schwarzschild published his experience in Audubon magazine. In it, he recommended a moratorium on hunting songbirds on Mt. Subasio. A torrent of mail opposing the hunt poured into the town of Assisi - so much that the mayor had to have his mail carted from the post office in a wheelbarrow, says Schwarzschild.
The issue of shooting songbirds spread to Italian newspapers and magazines. A ``bird day'' was celebrated in Assisi with musicians and a symbolic releasing of doves. And the newly elected minister of the environment, Alfredo Biondi, attended the celebration and declared that the birds should be brought back to Assisi. The issue became a national controversy that continues today.
Schwartzchild appealed to Italian pride: ```How can you, a civilized country with your traditions and your monuments of compassion - because the Italians by and large are very compassionate people,''' he told them, ```how can you allow this to happen?'''
``I can safely tell you that we were a catalyst in bringing together the conservation organizations in Italy who had been discouraged because the hunting lobby in Italy is so powerful,'' says Schwarzschild. ``It was our effort that got the media worked up.''
A moratorium has been placed on songbird hunting on Mt. Subasio, and the Italian government recently approved the boundaries of a park on the mountain, though no funds for the park have been set aside.
Assisi Nature Council/USA, 313 Goodhill Rd., Kentfield, CA, 94904.